January 21, 2015 An Overview of Pass-through Businesses in the United States Kyle Pomerleau Kyle Pomerleau Print this page Subscribe Support our work Download SPECIAL REPORT No. 227: An Overview of Pass-through Businesses in the United States (PDF) Key Findings Pass-through business income is taxed on the business owners’ tax returns through the individual income tax code. Pass-through business income faces marginal tax rates that exceed 50 percent in some U.S. states. Pass-through businesses face only one layer of tax on their profits compared to the double taxation faced by C corporations. The number of pass-through businesses has nearly tripled since 1980, while the number of traditional C corporations has declined. Pass-through businesses earn more net business income than C corporations. Pass-through businesses employed more than 50 percent of the private sector work force and accounted for 37 percent of total private sector payroll in 2011. Although pass-through businesses are smaller than C corporations on average, they are not all small businesses. Many people work for large pass-through companies. The majority of pass-through business income is taxed at top individual tax rates. Tax reform aimed at improving the competitiveness of U.S. businesses needs to address the individual income tax code due to the economic importance of pass-through businesses. Introduction One of the goals of tax reform is to improve the competitiveness of U.S. businesses and grow the economy. A promising way to do that is by lowering taxes on saving and investment through business tax reform. Much time is devoted to improving the corporate side of the tax code, but corporate-only business tax reform misses a significant portion of business activity. The United States currently has a large number of pass-through businesses, or businesses that pay their taxes through the individual income tax code rather than through the corporate code. These sole proprietorships, S corporations, and partnerships make up the vast majority of businesses and more than 60 percent of net business income in America. In addition, pass-through businesses account for more than half of the private sector workforce and 37 percent of total private sector payroll. Pass-through businesses are represented in all industries in the United States. Given that pass-through businesses are a significant part of the U.S. economy, tax reform should address the individual income tax code along with the corporate tax code. What Are Pass-through Businesses? Table 1. Major Types of Pass-through Businesses Legal Form Description Sole Proprietorship An unincorporated business owned by a single individual that reports its income on schedule C of the 1040 tax form. Partnership An unincorporated business with multiple owners, either individuals or other businesses. Limited Liability Company (LLC) A type of business that has limited liability like a traditional C corporation. S Corporation A domestic corporation that can only be owned by U.S. citizens (not other corporations or partnerships) and can only have up to 100 shareholders. Sole proprietorships, S corporations, limited liability companies (LLCs), and partnerships are also known as pass-through businesses (Table 1). These entities are called pass-throughs, because the profits of these firms are passed directly through the business to the owners and are taxed on the owners’ individual income tax returns. This is in contrast with traditional C corporations, which pay tax at the entity level through the corporate income tax. Their owners (shareholders) then pay tax on this income again when they receive a dividend or sell their stock and realize a capital gain. Another difference between pass-through businesses and traditional C corporations is that owners of pass-through businesses pay the full tax on their business’s income every year as the business earns it. Contrast this with owners or shareholders of C corporations, who can defer the taxation on their share of corporate income as long as the corporation retains its earnings or if the shareholder does not realize a capital gain on his stock. What Taxes Do Pass-through Businesses Pay? Since pass-through businesses pass their income and losses directly to their owners, these businesses face the same marginal tax rates as individuals. These rates start at 10 percent on the first $9,075 of taxable income ($18,150 married filed jointly) and rise to 39.6 percent on taxable income over $406,750 ($457,601 married filed jointly) (Table 2). Table 2. 2014 Federal Income Tax Brackets and Rates, Pass-through Businesses Rate Single Filers Married Joint Filers 10% $0 to $9,075 $0 to $18,150 15% $9,076 to $36,900 $18,151 to $73,800 25% $36,901 to $89,350 $73,801 to $148,850 28% $89,351 to $186,350 $148,851 to $226,850 33% $186,351 to $405,100 $226,851 to $405,100 35% $405,101 to 406,750 $405,101 to 457,600 39.6% $406,751+ $457,601+ Source: Internal Revenue Service. In addition, sole proprietorships and partnerships pay the self-employment (SE) tax. SE taxes are levied on self-employment income in order to fund both Social Security and Medicare and are ultimately equivalent to what wage earners pay in payroll taxes.[1] The SE payroll tax is a combined 15.3 percent on the first $117,000, 2.9 percent on the next $83,000, and 3.8 percent on any income above $200,000 ($250,000 for joint filers) (Table 3). Table 3. Payroll and Self-Employment Taxes for a Single Filer, 2014 Taxable Earnings Social Security Medicare Total $0–$117,000 12.40% 2.9% 15.3% $117,000–$200,000 0% 2.9% 2.9% $200,000 and over 0% 3.8% 3.8% Source: Social Security Administration. Owners of sole proprietorships and partnerships are subject to the SE payroll tax on most of their net business income.[2] S corporation owners are subject to SE payroll taxes on the portion of their net income paid out in wages. Specifically, an owner of an S corporation can designate his income as either a profit distribution or wages. The income designated as wages is subject to the SE tax while the non-wage income is not.[3] S corporation income earned by a passive shareholder—an S corporation owner that does not actively participate in the day-to-day activities of the business but still receives income [4]—is not subject to the SE payroll tax. However, a passive shareholder is liable for the 3.8 percent Net Investment Income Tax that was passed as part of the Affordable Care Act.[5] This tax applies to investment income when a taxpayer’s modified AGI exceeds $200,000 ($250,000 for joint filers). Pass-through business income can also be subject to the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT), which increases the effective tax rate paid by business owners.[6] In addition, pass-through businesses pay state and local income taxes, which vary from zero percent in states without personal income taxes to 13.3 percent, the top marginal income tax rate in California.[7] Combined, the top marginal income tax rates faced by pass-through businesses can exceed 50 percent in some cases. For example, the top marginal tax rate faced by sole proprietors in California tops 51.9 percent (see Table 4). The top marginal income tax rate for active shareholders of S corporations is slightly lower, since they do not pay the payroll tax on non-wage, business income (California’s top rate is 48.8 percent). [8] Passive S corporation shareholders in California face an effective marginal rate of 52.6 percent. Table 4. Top Marginal Tax Rate for a Sole Proprietorship in California Top Marginal Federal Income Tax 39.60% Top Marginal State Income Tax 13.30% Self-employment Tax 3.80% Deduction for State/Local Income Taxes and Self Employment Taxes (Less Pease) -4.80% Total 51.90% Source: Author’s calculations. The average top marginal income tax rate on sole proprietorships and partnerships in the United States is 47.2 percent, and 44.5 and 48.3 percent, respectively, for active and passive shareholders of S corporations.[9] Tax Differential with Traditional C Corporations Due to the different tax treatment of pass-through businesses and C corporations, the two business forms face a tax burden differential (see Table 5). C corporations are first taxed at the entity level at the 39.1 percent combined federal and average state tax rate.[10] Then, when those profits are realized by the owners (shareholders) as either dividends or capital gains, the owners pay taxes on that income again. The double-taxation of corporate income creates a disparity between the total tax burden on the income of pass-through businesses and C corporations. Pass-through businesses facing the top marginal tax rate (combined with the average state rate) face an average rate of 47.2 percent compared to an average total tax rate of 56.5 percent on C corporate income realized at the shareholder level. Table 5. Total Tax Burden on Business Income, C Corporation vs. Pass-through Business Traditional C corporation Pass-through business Entity-Level Tax 39.1% 0.0% Individual-Level Tax 28.6% 47.2% Total Tax Rate 56.5% 47.2% Note: Assumes C corporation distributes dividends. Pass-through business is a partnership. Source: Author’s calculations. Although traditional C corporations pay a higher overall tax rate on their income, there are specific advantages to the C corporate form that make it worthwhile for some businesses, specifically the ease of raising money, less restrictive shareholder rules (compared to an S corporation), deferral of domestic taxation on foreign income, and the ability to retain earnings without triggering shareholder taxation.[11] The Number of Pass-through Businesses Filing Tax Returns Has Greatly Increased Over the Past Thirty Years The number of pass-through businesses in the United States has increased considerably since the Tax Reform Act of 1986, which substantially lowered individual income tax rates.[12] Between 1980 and 2011, the number of pass-through business tax returns has increased by 175 percent from roughly 10.9 million returns to about 30 million returns (Figure 2).[13] The number of sole proprietorships increased from 8.9 million in 1980 to 23.4 million in 2011. The number of partnership businesses grew from 1.3 million returns to 3.2 million returns. S corporations experienced the fastest growth during this period. From 1980 to 2011, the number of S corporations filing tax returns grew from approximately 545,000 returns to over 4.15 million; an increase of 660 percent, more than three times the rate of growth experienced by pass-through businesses overall. The number of C corporations filing tax returns during this period steadily declined from 2.2 million returns in 1980 to 1.6 million returns in 2011. Pass-through Businesses Are the Most Common Business Form in the United States Pass-through businesses are the most common business form in the United States. Of the 27.7 million firms in 2011,[14] about 94 percent of them were pass-through businesses according to the Census Bureau (Figure 3).[15] Sole proprietorships comprise the majority of all business forms. According to Census data, 73.1 percent of all businesses were sole proprietorships (20.3 million firms). 13.1 percent of all businesses were S corporations (3.65 million firms), and about 8 percent were partnerships (2.2 million firms). C corporations make up the remaining 5.6 percent of businesses in the United States (1.5 million firms). Pass-through Businesses Now Earn More Net Income Than Traditional C Corporations As the number of pass-through businesses increased, they began to generate more net business income as a group than traditional C corporations. The combined net income of sole proprietorships, partnerships, and S corporations in 1980 was $188 billion compared to total C corporate net income of $697 billion (Figure 4).[16] By 1998, net pass-through income had grown by 340 percent to $829 billion, overtaking C corporate income—$773 billion in 1998—for the first time. Pass-through business income has been persistently higher than corporate income since 1998, with the exception of 2005, when corporate net income peaked at $1.6 trillion. The most recent data shows that pass-through businesses earned $1.3 trillion in net income, or 63.9 percent of total business net income in 2011. Most of the Private Sector Workforce Works at, or Is Self-Employed as, a Pass-through Business Not only do pass-through businesses earn more net income than traditional C corporations, they also account for more employment. According to 2011 Census data, pass-through businesses account for 55.2 percent of all private sector employment.[17] This represents 65.7 million workers. In contrast, traditional C corporations comprise 44.7 percent of the private sector workforce, or 53.2 million workers. S corporations account for the most employment of all pass-through business types. In 2011, S corporations employed 24.4 percent of the private sector workforce, or 29 million workers. Sole Proprietorships comprised 19.5 percent of the private sector workforce. Partnerships accounted for the lowest amount of employment with only 11.3 percent of the private sector workforce. Pass-Through Businesses Are Generally Smaller Than C Corporations, but Pass-Through Businesses Are Not Always Small Businesses A major reason why C corporations account for a significant amount of employment but so few firms is that they are significantly larger than pass-through businesses on average. Figure 6, below, compares the distribution of pass-through and corporate employment by the size of firm. Employment at C corporations is heavily concentrated in large firms. In 2011, 72.3 percent (38 million) of C corporate workers were employed at large firms with 500 or more employees with an additional 8.9 percent (4.7 million) working at firms with between 100 and 500 employees.[18] The remaining 18.7 percent (9.9 million) of corporate employment was at firms with fewer than 100 employees. Pass-through business employment is more heavily distributed among smaller firms. However, it would be a mistake to completely conflate pass-through businesses with small businesses. While most pass-through employment is either self-employment (33.6 percent) or at small firms with between 1 and 100 employees (38.7 percent), a significant number of employees work at large pass-through businesses. According to 2011 Census data, a combined 27.5 percent (18.1 million) of pass-through employment was at firms with more than 100 employees, and 15.9 percent (10.3 million) of pass-through employees work at large firms with 500 or more employees. Pass-through Businesses Account for Most of the Private Sector Workforce in 48 States The prevalence of pass-through employment varies among U.S. states. According to Census Bureau data, pass-through businesses accounted more than 60 percent of business employment in eight states: Idaho (64 percent), Maine (62.4 percent), Montana (67.9 percent), North Dakota (60.5 percent), Rhode Island (60.6 percent), South Dakota (64.7 percent), Vermont (63.1 percent), and Wyoming (61.8 percent). [19] In contrast, Delaware (49.5 percent) and Hawaii (48 percent) had pass-through employment as a share of total private sector employment of less than 50 percent.[20] Pass-Through Businesses Accounted for Nearly 40 Percent of Private Sector Payroll Pass-through businesses also account for a significant amount of private sector payroll. Of the $4.48 trillion of salaries and wages paid in 2011, pass-through businesses accounted for approximately $1.65 trillion, or 37 percent (Figure 8).[21] S corporations accounted for most pass-through business payroll with a total of $1 trillion. Partnerships paid $505 billion and sole proprietorships paid $98 billion.[22] However, given their larger size, C corporations accounted for most of the private sector payroll in the United States. In 2011, 63 percent of private sector payroll was paid by C corporations, or $2.8 trillion.[23] Pass-through Businesses Employ the Majority of Workers in Service Sector Industries Pass-through businesses employ workers in every industry. However, service sector industries have larger shares of pass-through employment than corporate employment. In contrast, manufacturing and trade industries are dominated by C corporate employment. Figure 9 shows the share of corporate versus pass-through employment by industry. According to Census data, pass-through business employment accounts for most employment in most industries. Pass-through employment accounts for 60 percent or more employment in the Arts, Entertainment, and Food Service (72.1 percent); Utilities, Construction, and Transportation (60.8 percent); and Information, Education, and Healthcare (60.3 percent) industries.[24] C corporations accounted for a majority of employment in only three major industries: manufacturing (63.7 percent); wholesale and retail trade (58 percent); and Finance, Insurance, and Real Estate (50.6 percent). Although C corporations accounted for more employment in these industries, there are consistently more pass-through businesses (firms) in all industries. For example, most employment in manufacturing is at C corporations, but the vast majority of manufacturing firms are pass-through businesses.[25] (See Appendix for complete industry numbers.) High Income Individuals Report Most Pass-through Business Income Since pass-through business income is taxed at the individual level, the distribution of pass-through income across individuals is important in understanding the effect of individual marginal tax rates. If most pass-through business income were earned by low to moderate income individuals, pass-through business income would face relatively low marginal rates. Conversely, if most business income is earned by high-income individuals, pass-through business income would be taxed at potentially high marginal rates. According to IRS data, 72 percent of returns with business income reported between $1 and $100,000 in business income.[26] However, these returns only accounted for 14 percent of total business income.[27] The largest concentration of pass-through business income was reported on the 1.3 percent of returns that earned $1 million in net business income or more. This group of taxpayers earned 37 percent of total pass-through business income. Combined with the 1.8 percent of tax returns with business income between $500,000 and $1 million, 51 percent of business income was earned by the few taxpayers (3.1 percent of returns) with net business income of $500,000 or more. This means that 51 percent of pass-through business income in 2012 was potentially subject to the federal top marginal tax rate on individual income of 39.6 percent. Conclusion In the last thirty years, the number of pass-through businesses has greatly increased while the number of C corporations has declined. As a result, pass-through businesses now account for 94 percent of all businesses, earn more than 64 percent of total business net income, and employ more than half of the private sector workforce in the United States. In addition, they pay more than $1.6 trillion in wages and salaries and operate in every U.S. industry. One of the main goals of fundamental tax reform is to make U.S. businesses more competitive and to increase economic growth. This requires a reduction in taxes on businesses and investment. Most attention is given to traditional C corporations because they face high tax burdens by international standards and account for a large amount of economic activity. As a result, less attention has been given to pass-through businesses. Since pass-through businesses now account for more than half of the business income and employment in the United States, any business tax reform needs to address the individual income tax code as well as the corporate income tax code. Appendix Appendix Table 1. Combined Top Marginal Tax Rate on Pass-through Businesses by State, 2014 State Top Marginal Income Tax Rate (Sole Proprietorships/Partnerships) Top Marginal Income Tax Rate (S Corporations) Active Shareholders Passive Shareholders Alabama 45.65% 42.67% 46.47% Alaska 42.58% 39.60% 43.40% Arizona 46.51% 43.53% 47.33% Arkansas 48.00% 45.02% 48.82% California 51.86% 48.88% 52.68% Colorado 46.56% 43.58% 47.38% Connecticut 47.81% 44.83% 48.63% Delaware 47.81% 44.83% 48.63% Florida 42.58% 39.60% 43.40% Georgia 47.39% 44.41% 48.21% Hawaii 50.41% 47.43% 51.23% Idaho 48.24% 45.26% 49.06% Illinois 46.79% 43.81% 47.61% Indiana 46.61% 43.63% 47.43% Iowa 47.22% 44.25% 48.05% Kansas 42.58% 39.60% 43.40% Kentucky 48.30% 45.32% 49.12% Louisiana 45.96% 42.98% 46.78% Maine 48.57% 45.59% 49.39% Maryland 49.05% 46.07% 49.87% Massachusetts 46.91% 43.93% 47.73% Michigan 46.52% 43.54% 47.34% Minnesota 49.72% 46.74% 50.54% Mississippi 46.79% 43.81% 47.61% Missouri 47.51% 44.53% 48.33% Montana 47.93% 44.96% 48.76% Nebraska 47.90% 44.92% 48.72% Nevada 42.58% 39.60% 43.40% New Hampshire 42.58% 39.60% 43.40% New Jersey 49.18% 46.21% 50.01% New Mexico 46.73% 43.75% 47.55% New York 50.24% 47.26% 51.06% North Carolina 47.27% 44.29% 48.09% North Dakota 45.71% 42.73% 46.53% Ohio 48.01% 45.03% 48.83% Oklahoma 46.94% 43.96% 47.76% Oregon 49.81% 46.83% 50.63% Pennsylvania 46.53% 43.55% 47.35% Rhode Island 47.38% 44.41% 48.21% South Carolina 48.00% 45.02% 48.82% South Dakota 42.58% 39.60% 43.40% Tennessee 42.58% 44.41% 48.21% Texas 42.58% 39.60% 43.40% Utah 46.79% 43.81% 47.61% Vermont 49.17% 46.19% 49.99% Virginia 47.24% 44.26% 48.06% Washington 42.58% 39.60% 43.40% West Virginia 47.69% 44.71% 48.51% Wisconsin 48.39% 45.41% 49.21% Wyoming 42.58% 39.60% 43.40% District of Columbia 49.17% 46.19% 49.99% U.S. Average 47.25% 44.51% 48.31% Note: Many states also apply gross receipts, margin, and franchise taxes to pass-through business income. These numbers do not account for those. Source: Author’s calculations. Appendix Table 2. Employment by Business Form and State, 2011 State C Corporations Pass-through Total Sole Proprietorship Partnership S Corporations Share Employment Share Employment Share Employment Share Employment Share Employment Alabama 44.66% 759,390 55.34% 941,143 19.86% 337,810 10.38% 176,477 25.10% 426,856 Alaska 40.87% 109,453 59.13% 158,359 22.64% 60,631 11.60% 31,054 24.90% 66,674 Arizona 47.42% 1,082,867 52.58% 1,200,610 17.43% 397,950 12.50% 285,528 22.65% 517,132 Arkansas 45.68% 470,789 54.32% 559,763 19.41% 200,025 10.43% 107,464 24.48% 252,274 California 44.79% 6,281,899 55.21% 7,743,121 22.55% 3,162,609 9.67% 1,356,736 22.99% 3,223,776 Colorado 43.28% 940,781 56.72% 1,233,139 18.54% 402,999 13.04% 283,389 25.15% 546,751 Connecticut 46.90% 670,857 53.10% 759,461 20.03% 286,557 14.79% 211,596 18.27% 261,308 Delaware 50.50% 183,955 49.50% 180,326 13.57% 49,425 13.63% 49,656 22.30% 81,245 District of Columbia 47.72% 167,067 52.28% 183,012 15.44% 54,037 21.26% 74,435 15.58% 54,540 Florida 43.30% 3,347,252 56.70% 4,382,664 19.28% 1,490,678 9.57% 739,885 27.84% 2,152,101 Georgia 46.21% 1,728,269 53.79% 2,011,755 20.61% 770,791 9.64% 360,372 23.55% 880,592 Hawaii 51.96% 262,206 48.04% 242,420 20.58% 103,853 10.32% 52,053 17.14% 86,514 Idaho 35.98% 192,506 64.02% 342,513 21.29% 113,916 15.06% 80,578 27.67% 148,019 Illinois 45.65% 2,381,740 54.35% 2,836,017 17.50% 912,902 9.85% 513,968 27.01% 1,409,147 Indiana 41.98% 1,036,757 58.02% 1,433,031 16.49% 407,276 11.75% 290,192 29.78% 735,563 Iowa 46.27% 570,868 53.73% 662,857 17.63% 217,458 8.79% 108,486 27.31% 336,913 Kansas 46.70% 526,274 53.30% 600,592 18.27% 205,836 10.72% 120,835 24.31% 273,921 Kentucky 44.34% 677,683 55.66% 850,549 19.90% 304,105 11.74% 179,351 24.02% 367,093 Louisiana 41.03% 712,283 58.97% 1,023,924 20.02% 347,506 15.05% 261,321 23.91% 415,097 Maine 37.64% 182,221 62.36% 301,958 24.41% 118,201 8.29% 40,159 29.66% 143,598 Maryland 43.75% 952,896 56.25% 1,225,339 20.13% 438,505 10.55% 229,728 25.58% 557,106 Massachusetts 47.52% 1,322,241 52.48% 1,460,544 18.21% 506,686 9.62% 267,801 24.65% 686,057 Michigan 43.80% 1,553,073 56.20% 1,992,942 19.41% 688,336 11.44% 405,675 25.35% 898,931 Minnesota 43.94% 1,012,541 56.06% 1,291,745 17.43% 401,737 8.43% 194,226 30.20% 695,782 Mississippi 44.65% 425,946 55.35% 528,010 22.49% 214,554 11.23% 107,121 21.63% 206,335 Missouri 46.72% 1,076,499 53.28% 1,227,605 18.39% 423,710 10.66% 245,567 24.23% 558,328 Montana 32.10% 113,952 67.90% 241,049 23.97% 85,091 11.13% 39,516 32.80% 116,442 Nebraska 44.02% 350,531 55.98% 445,817 16.58% 132,034 8.72% 69,434 30.68% 244,349 Nevada 46.82% 530,211 53.18% 602,201 17.00% 192,474 15.32% 173,438 20.87% 236,289 New Hampshire 44.65% 250,754 55.35% 310,874 20.67% 116,064 9.60% 53,901 25.09% 140,909 New Jersey 45.46% 1,617,960 54.54% 1,941,400 17.12% 609,281 13.66% 486,253 23.76% 845,866 New Mexico 41.31% 262,688 58.69% 373,147 20.85% 132,589 12.97% 82,499 24.86% 158,059 New York 40.69% 2,985,817 59.31% 4,351,881 21.13% 1,550,289 12.49% 916,635 25.69% 1,884,957 North Carolina 45.56% 1,576,409 54.44% 1,883,894 19.20% 664,216 9.47% 327,524 25.78% 892,154 North Dakota 39.54% 111,283 60.46% 170,176 18.77% 52,831 10.37% 29,201 31.32% 88,144 Ohio 46.43% 2,071,166 53.57% 2,389,484 17.68% 788,483 11.40% 508,487 24.49% 1,092,514 Oklahoma 42.23% 573,296 57.77% 784,340 20.33% 276,021 13.08% 177,594 24.36% 330,725 Oregon 42.03% 577,733 57.97% 796,751 19.97% 274,531 11.04% 151,715 26.96% 370,505 Pennsylvania 44.64% 2,150,826 55.36% 2,667,428 18.03% 868,870 10.54% 507,738 26.79% 1,290,820 Rhode Island 39.39% 152,988 60.61% 235,359 19.30% 74,945 8.40% 32,629 32.90% 127,785 South Carolina 45.77% 751,398 54.23% 890,332 19.01% 312,102 10.95% 179,753 24.27% 398,477 South Dakota 35.27% 111,142 64.73% 203,998 20.85% 65,698 11.28% 35,561 32.60% 102,739 Tennessee 48.72% 1,193,808 51.28% 1,256,432 22.21% 544,306 14.90% 364,991 14.17% 347,135 Texas 46.72% 4,715,695 53.28% 5,378,460 21.02% 2,121,668 14.54% 1,468,145 17.72% 1,788,647 Utah 42.84% 472,883 57.16% 630,968 15.39% 169,915 14.84% 163,839 26.93% 297,214 Vermont 36.88% 96,160 63.12% 164,610 26.69% 69,589 9.45% 24,653 26.98% 70,368 Virginia 48.01% 1,521,565 51.99% 1,647,972 16.81% 532,800 10.01% 317,146 25.18% 798,026 Washington 45.23% 1,087,939 54.77% 1,317,293 18.45% 443,831 10.73% 258,114 25.58% 615,348 West Virginia 48.80% 270,479 51.20% 283,815 19.43% 107,701 11.77% 65,268 20.00% 110,846 Wisconsin 44.03% 1,002,392 55.97% 1,274,178 16.53% 376,296 9.90% 225,355 29.54% 672,527 Wyoming 38.17% 86,542 61.83% 140,161 20.13% 45,631 13.22% 29,965 28.48% 64,565 Source: Author’s calculations based on U.S. Census data. Appendix Table 3. Payroll by Business Form and State, 2011 State C Corporate Payroll Pass-Through Payroll Sole Proprietorship Payroll Partnership Payroll S Corporation Payroll Share Amount Share Amount Share Amount Share Amount Share Amount Alabama 60.5% $32,007,619 39.5% $20,921,116 2.3% $1,242,116 9.35% $4,948,624 27.8% $14,730,376 Alaska 58.9% $6,837,634 41.1% $4,777,962 3.9% $450,529 10.87% $1,263,055 26.4% $3,064,378 Arizona 66.4% $50,723,125 33.6% $25,705,549 1.5% $1,138,622 10.18% $7,778,764 22.0% $16,788,163 Arkansas 65.0% $19,880,118 35.0% $10,727,277 1.8% $548,160 9.68% $2,962,057 23.6% $7,217,060 California 66.3% $391,528,884 33.7% $199,022,094 2.5% $14,631,666 9.64% $56,916,574 21.6% $127,473,854 Colorado 62.2% $51,740,233 37.8% $31,422,572 1.5% $1,285,006 11.89% $9,889,960 24.3% $20,247,606 Connecticut 65.0% $45,463,512 35.0% $24,480,045 2.6% $1,806,889 15.18% $10,618,564 17.2% $12,054,592 Delaware 63.1% $9,733,653 36.9% $5,699,143 1.4% $221,388 17.36% $2,679,297 18.1% $2,798,458 District of Columbia 56.5% $12,464,549 43.5% $9,595,380 2.9% $630,936 27.74% $6,119,752 12.9% $2,844,692 Florida 59.9% $142,247,165 40.1% $95,084,198 1.3% $3,105,904 10.41% $24,716,547 28.3% $67,261,747 Georgia 66.1% $83,965,206 33.9% $43,133,496 1.6% $1,976,450 9.93% $12,619,545 22.5% $28,537,501 Hawaii 68.3% $10,349,394 31.7% $4,807,095 3.6% $549,641 10.35% $1,568,729 17.7% $2,688,725 Idaho 52.5% $7,778,024 47.5% $7,026,080 2.2% $320,483 15.97% $2,364,049 29.3% $4,341,548 Illinois 62.0% $132,851,641 38.0% $81,256,813 2.1% $4,574,599 11.38% $24,375,339 24.4% $52,306,875 Indiana 57.4% $47,204,435 42.6% $35,090,766 2.1% $1,724,555 11.25% $9,255,257 29.3% $24,110,954 Iowa 63.3% $24,808,579 36.7% $14,408,835 2.2% $844,610 6.90% $2,704,843 27.7% $10,859,382 Kansas 65.0% $24,718,807 35.0% $13,321,261 2.2% $828,865 8.77% $3,336,798 24.1% $9,155,598 Kentucky 61.7% $28,913,905 38.3% $17,918,397 3.8% $1,788,935 10.67% $4,994,966 23.8% $11,134,496 Louisiana 55.6% $32,183,055 44.4% $25,695,038 2.3% $1,350,352 16.15% $9,344,547 25.9% $15,000,139 Maine 56.3% $7,762,347 43.7% $6,035,022 3.2% $438,128 7.41% $1,021,861 33.2% $4,575,033 Maryland 59.9% $51,226,319 40.1% $34,226,875 2.2% $1,913,324 9.98% $8,531,057 27.8% $23,782,494 Massachusetts 66.7% $89,890,293 33.3% $44,910,224 1.7% $2,327,184 9.78% $13,178,838 21.8% $29,404,202 Michigan 62.3% $78,744,124 37.7% $47,663,679 1.9% $2,449,317 10.78% $13,623,258 25.0% $31,591,104 Minnesota 63.8% $59,108,837 36.2% $33,589,449 1.9% $1,764,278 7.62% $7,059,076 26.7% $24,766,095 Mississippi 62.9% $15,818,019 37.1% $9,310,039 2.8% $698,193 10.93% $2,747,398 23.3% $5,864,448 Missouri 64.7% $50,397,113 35.3% $27,542,251 1.9% $1,486,279 9.51% $7,411,191 23.9% $18,644,781 Montana 51.2% $4,632,791 48.8% $4,423,065 2.9% $259,706 9.29% $841,740 36.7% $3,321,619 Nebraska 58.8% $15,008,653 41.2% $10,536,723 1.7% $443,661 6.90% $1,763,625 32.6% $8,329,437 Nevada 59.2% $21,750,823 40.8% $14,967,337 4.1% $1,497,066 14.65% $5,377,575 22.0% $8,092,696 New Hampshire 61.6% $12,618,559 38.4% $7,856,197 3.0% $620,889 7.10% $1,453,691 28.2% $5,781,617 New Jersey 64.5% $106,136,669 35.5% $58,534,325 2.0% $3,235,618 10.88% $17,912,850 22.7% $37,385,857 New Mexico 56.4% $10,599,304 43.6% $8,204,404 2.7% $512,359 15.03% $2,825,448 25.9% $4,866,597 New York 59.9% $218,057,598 40.1% $146,082,409 2.1% $7,636,085 16.49% $60,063,617 21.5% $78,382,707 North Carolina 65.0% $73,648,168 35.0% $39,575,743 1.9% $2,183,591 8.59% $9,723,911 24.4% $27,668,241 North Dakota 57.0% $5,435,830 43.0% $4,099,686 2.3% $217,953 7.94% $757,496 32.8% $3,124,237 Ohio 63.7% $99,012,006 36.3% $56,340,183 2.1% $3,266,377 10.12% $15,722,600 24.0% $37,351,206 Oklahoma 60.8% $26,676,707 39.2% $17,185,828 2.4% $1,032,740 12.38% $5,428,372 24.5% $10,724,716 Oregon 63.0% $29,763,256 37.0% $17,498,294 2.3% $1,072,023 8.37% $3,955,555 26.4% $12,470,716 Pennsylvania 61.1% $111,739,161 38.9% $71,289,612 2.6% $4,823,178 9.53% $17,438,586 26.8% $49,027,848 Rhode Island 54.1% $7,406,493 45.9% $6,294,069 4.6% $625,134 7.34% $1,005,234 34.0% $4,663,701 South Carolina 62.2% $29,860,505 37.8% $18,155,968 2.3% $1,107,622 10.60% $5,091,516 24.9% $11,956,830 South Dakota 49.6% $4,249,432 50.4% $4,325,195 2.8% $243,397 10.20% $874,870 37.4% $3,206,928 Tennessee 66.6% $53,449,846 33.4% $26,780,728 3.1% $2,481,896 13.86% $11,118,643 16.4% $13,180,189 Texas 65.5% $249,208,105 34.5% $131,034,636 2.3% $8,837,959 15.18% $57,711,580 17.0% $64,485,097 Utah 60.7% $21,540,940 39.3% $13,958,186 1.2% $419,387 11.21% $3,979,060 26.9% $9,559,739 Vermont 56.6% $4,248,011 43.4% $3,255,347 3.5% $265,584 7.24% $543,079 32.6% $2,446,684 Virginia 63.5% $82,006,387 36.5% $47,083,789 1.9% $2,401,574 9.68% $12,501,885 24.9% $32,180,330 Washington 65.7% $67,815,134 34.3% $35,472,191 2.5% $2,573,819 8.62% $8,906,822 23.2% $23,991,550 West Virginia 66.9% $11,431,956 33.1% $5,666,790 3.4% $581,332 10.32% $1,763,804 19.4% $3,321,654 Wisconsin 60.4% $48,179,529 39.6% $31,615,544 2.3% $1,854,671 7.78% $6,204,305 29.5% $23,556,568 Wyoming 56.1% $4,545,034 43.9% $3,559,474 2.3% $188,161 10.63% $861,799 31.0% $2,509,514 Note: Does not include non-employer firms; dollar amounts in thousands. Source: Author’s calculations based on U.S. Census data. Appendix Table 4. Pass-through Businesses, Employment, and Payroll by Industry NAICS Classification NAICS Code Total Private Sector C Corporations Pass-through Businesses Firms Employment Payroll Firms Employment Payroll Firms Employment Payroll Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting 11 258188 386229 $5,186,733 6767 50678 $1,957,557 251421 335551 $3,229,176 Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction 21 131247 758959 $55,142,854 8863 433115 $39,779,751 122384 325844 $15,363,103 Utilities 22 20703 580534 $52,791,916 2159 537163 $50,520,384 18544 43371 $2,271,532 Construction 23 3032846 7570862 $264,873,890 180636 1862122 $101,836,009 2852210 5708740 $163,037,881 Manufacturing 31-33 585945 11237036 $571,217,485 95521 7160805 $406,976,997 490424 4076231 $164,240,488 Wholesale trade 42 712192 5955180 $353,649,072 129530 3223821 $230,411,033 582662 2731359 $123,238,039 Retail trade 44-45 2498799 16365278 $366,560,872 191122 9735727 $233,317,378 2307677 6629551 $133,243,494 Transportation and warehousing 48-49 1202842 5115544 $174,926,243 62017 2794022 $125,680,588 1140825 2321522 $49,245,655 Information 51 383354 3340315 $229,570,366 29305 2323834 $188,692,027 354049 1016481 $40,878,339 Finance and insurance 52 940019 6214086 $472,183,897 63534 4461143 $376,795,088 876485 1752943 $95,388,809 Real estate and rental and leasing 53 2604917 4209817 $82,333,393 132816 823592 $36,584,148 2472101 3386225 $45,749,245 Professional, scientific, and technical services 54 3924278 10847469 $551,274,359 200958 3681456 $302,677,017 3723320 7166013 $248,597,342 Management of companies and enterprises 55 25009 2605175 $278,703,195 12321 2131746 $240,527,725 12688 473429 $38,175,470 Administrative and support and waste management and remediation services 56 2301092 11257122 $321,620,087 79696 4547393 $176,609,396 2221396 6709729 $145,010,691 Educational services 61 630490 1405289 $25,206,522 13364 400570 $14,262,759 617126 1004719 $10,943,763 Health care and social assistance 62 2534133 10742519 $367,325,270 125854 3421261 $175,269,506 2408279 7321258 $192,055,764 Arts, entertainment, and recreation 71 1277971 2545644 $47,681,968 31199 541619 $16,208,131 1246772 2004025 $31,473,837 Accommodation and food services 72 824512 11744451 $190,190,752 100135 4130380 $77,708,593 724377 7614071 $112,482,159 Other services (except public administration) 81 3905021 6121087 $73,832,944 124134 1000942 $31,498,530 3780887 5120145 $42,334,414 Industries not classified 99 15970 3716 $262,048 2123 2544 $54,870 13847 1172 $207,178 Note: Dollars in thousands of dollars. Source: Author’s calculations based on U.S. Census data. [1] Half of a worker’s payroll taxes are paid by their employer. [2] Rental real estate income is exempt from the self-employment tax. [3] The IRS sets a limit on how much income an owner can designate as a non-wage distribution to prevent abuse. [4] The IRS sets guidelines on what they consider active or passive participation. If shareholders do not satisfy the “material participation” guidelines, the income received from the business is deemed passive and subject to the Net Investment Income Tax. See Michael Kosnitzky & Michael Grisolia, Net Investment Income Tax Regulations Affecting S Corporations, http://www.bsfllp.com/news/in_the_news/001548/_res/id=sa_File1/. [5] Regulations require equal distribution among all S corporation shareholders, active or passive. S corporations must distribute enough money to all shareholders, including active shareholders, to cover the 3.8 percent Net Investment Tax, even though active shareholders are not actually required to pay the tax. Although not strictly a tax on S corporations, this limits the amount of money available for reinvestment. [6] More than 2 million income tax returns with pass-through business income were subject to the AMT in 2007. U.S. Department of the Treasury, Office of Tax Analysis, Mathew Knittel et al., OTA Technical Paper 4: Methodology to Identify Small Businesses and Their Owners (Aug. 2011), http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/tax-policy/tax-analysis/Documents/OTA-T2011-04-Small-Business-Methodology-Aug-8-2011.pdf. [7] Tax Foundation, State Personal Income Tax Rates and Brackets 2014 Update, https://taxfoundation.org/article/state-personal-income-tax-rates-and-brackets-2014-update. [8] Assuming the last dollar earned by an active shareholder is his non-salary income from his business. [9] Averages are both weighted by the amount of pass-through income in each state. Assumes no effect of Pease in states with no individual income tax. Pease may apply in states with no income tax, in some cases adding 1.118 percent to the marginal rate. Many states also apply gross receipts, margin, and franchise taxes to pass-through business income. These numbers do not account for those. [10] Assuming equity-financed investment. [11] Nearly 40 percent of corporate equities are held by tax-exempt organizations and individuals (college endowments, pension funds, and tax preferred retirement accounts). The corporate income passed to these taxpayers is exempt from the second layer of tax. See Congressional Budget Office, Taxing Capital Income: Effective Marginal Tax Rates Under 2014 Law and Selected Policy Options (Dec. 2014), http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/49817-Taxing_Capital_Income_0.pdf. [12] The top marginal individual income tax rates were reduced from 50 percent in 1986 to 28 percent in 1988. This is compared to the corporate income tax rate that was lowered from 46 percent in 1986 to 34 percent in 1988. See Tax Foundation, U.S. Federal Individual Income Tax Rates History, 1862-2013 (Nominal and Inflation-Adjusted Brackets), https://taxfoundation.org/article/us-federal-individual-income-tax-rates-history-1913-2013-nominal-and-inflation-adjusted-brackets; Tax Foundation, U.S. Federal Individual Income Tax Rates History, 1862-2013 (Nominal and Inflation-Adjusted Brackets), https://taxfoundation.org/article/us-federal-individual-income-tax-rates-history-1913-2013-nominal-and-inflation-adjusted-brackets. [13] Internal Revenue Service, SOI Tax Stats – Integrated Business Data, 1980–2008, http://www.irs.gov/uac/SOI-Tax-Stats-Integrated-Business-Data; Internal Revenue Service, Business Tax Statistics, 2009–2011, http://www.irs.gov/uac/Tax-Stats-2. IRS data double counts some businesses due to the fact that some private partnerships can be owned by one or more other business entities. [14] The number of firms differs from the number of returns. Specifically, an individual firm may own several different businesses that separately file tax returns. [15] Census Bureau, County Business Patterns, http://www.census.gov/econ/cbp/; Census Bureau, Nonemployer Statistics, http://www.census.gov/econ/nonemployer/. 2011 is the most up-to-date year for all data sources. [16] Internal Revenue Service, SOI Tax Stats – Integrated Business Data, 1980–2008, http://www.irs.gov/uac/SOI-Tax-Stats-Integrated-Business-Data; Internal Revenue Service, Business Tax Statistics, 2009–2011, http://www.irs.gov/uac/Tax-Stats-2. [17] Numbers include self-employed individuals in order to get a complete picture of employment by business form. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns, http://www.census.gov/econ/cbp/; Census Bureau, Statistics of U.S. Businesses, http://www.census.gov/econ/susb/; Census Bureau, Nonemployer Statistics 2011, http://www.census.gov/econ/nonemployer/. [18] Census Bureau, County Business Patterns, http://www.census.gov/econ/cbp/; Census Bureau, Statistics of U.S. Businesses, http://www.census.gov/econ/susb/; Census Bureau, Nonemployer Statistics 2011, http://www.census.gov/econ/nonemployer/. [19] Census Bureau, County Business Patterns, http://www.census.gov/econ/cbp/; Census Bureau, Statistics of U.S. Businesses, http://www.census.gov/econ/susb/; Census Bureau, Nonemployer Statistics 2011, http://www.census.gov/econ/nonemployer/. [20] See Appendix for full employment data table. [21] Census Bureau, County Business Patterns, http://www.census.gov/econ/cbp/; Census Bureau, Statistics of U.S. Businesses, http://www.census.gov/econ/susb/; Census Bureau, Nonemployer Statistics 2011, http://www.census.gov/econ/nonemployer/. [22] These numbers do not account for self-employment income, which is disproportionately earned by pass-through businesses, especially sole proprietorships. Unincorporated self-employed individuals reported approximately $600 billion in gross receipts in 2011. However, gross receipts cannot be directly compared to payroll due to the omission of business expenses. Wages would more accurately be compared to gross receipts minus costs. [23] See Appendix for full data table with payroll by state and business form for 2011. [24] Census Bureau, County Business Patterns, http://www.census.gov/econ/cbp/; Census Bureau, Statistics of U.S. Businesses, http://www.census.gov/econ/susb/; Census Bureau, Nonemployer Statistics 2011, http://www.census.gov/econ/nonemployer/. [25] Robert Carroll & Gerald Prante, The Flow-Through Business Sector and Tax Reform: The economic footprint of the flow-through sector and the potential impact of tax reform (Apr. 2011), http://www.s-corp.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/Flow-Through-Report-Final-2011-04-08.pdf. [26] Internal Revenue Service, SOI Tax Stats – Individual Statistical Tables by Size of Adjusted Gross Income, Table 1.4, http://www.irs.gov/uac/SOI-Tax-Stats—Individual-Statistical-Tables-by-Size-of-Adjusted-Gross-Income. Business income includes: business and professional income (Schedule C, 1040 Line 12), Rents, Royalties, S Corporation and Partnerships income (Schedule E), and Farm Income (Schedule F). [27] It is important to note that individuals can report business income from incidental business activity. For example, an individual can earn rental income from a vacation home. Topics Center for Federal Tax Policy Business Taxes Research Small Business Taxes Tags Capital Stock Tax (Franchise Tax) Pass-Throughs
