Mississippi Turns to Lottery, Other Tax Changes, in Special Session to Fund Bridge Repair
August 30, 2018
In a five-day special session that concluded August 29th, Mississippi lawmakers reached an agreement to reduce the state’s $400 million per year infrastructure funding shortfall, a plan that includes several tax changes. As of mid-August, more than 400 locally-owned bridges remained closed, with another 1,700 subject to weight restrictions, due to safety concerns and insufficient funding for repairs.
The Mississippi Legislature considered three bills during the special session, all part of a broader infrastructure plan spearheaded by Governor Phil Bryant (R), which garnered support from both sides of the aisle. Two of the bills, Senate Bill 2001 and House Bill 1, have notable tax implications.
Senate Bill 2001 establishes a state lottery with proceeds dedicated to infrastructure through June 2028. Under this legislation, at least 50 percent of gross revenue from the sale of lottery tickets must be awarded in prize money, while no more than 15 percent can be used to cover the overhead costs of administering the lottery. The remaining proceeds, around 35 percent of gross revenue from the sale of lottery tickets, will be transferred to the State Highway Fund.
Early projections indicate the lottery could generate approximately $80 million annually for infrastructure. However, legislators should use caution to avoid overestimating long-term lottery revenue projections. While some Southeastern states have seen growth in their inflation-adjusted lottery revenues over the past decade, more states have seen their lottery revenues decline, particularly those states that have had a lottery for several decades. Further, as Mississippi already has a riverboat gaming industry, the new lottery could potentially cannibalize some of that revenue.
Until now, Mississippi was among six states without a lottery. While playing the lottery is voluntary, paying the excise tax implicit in the price of lottery tickets is not voluntary. The lottery tax should therefore be regarded similarly to other excise taxes, such as those levied on alcohol and cigarettes.
As a supplement to the lottery, House Bill 1, the Mississippi Infrastructure Modernization Act, makes several tax changes designed to increase funding for Mississippi’s roads and bridges, including:
- A provision to dedicate a portion of Mississippi’s use tax revenue toward infrastructure. By August 2020, 30 percent of Mississippi’s use tax revenue will be dedicated to assisting counties and municipalities with infrastructure repair and construction, and 5 percent will be transferred to the Local System Bridge Replacement and Rehabilitation Fund. Following the U.S. Supreme Court’s Wayfair decision, the Mississippi Department of Revenue issued guidance expanding online sales tax collection responsibilities to remote sellers beginning September 1, 2018. However, policymakers should consider further legislative changes to improve the viability of Mississippi’s remote sales tax collection laws in the event of a legal challenge.
- A new annual motor vehicle privilege tax of $150 for electric vehicles and $75 for hybrid vehicles. This tax rate will adjust for inflation starting in 2021. Mississippi already levies privilege taxes on other motor vehicles that vary by vehicle type, including standard passenger vehicles, motorcycles, and pickup trucks. The relatively higher taxes on electric and hybrid vehicles appear designed to compensate for lower overall gas tax revenue generated by those vehicles, but this type of tax does not take into account the amount of driving a taxpayer does in a given year and is therefore a limited proxy for road usage.
- A new “environmental protection fee” levied on motor fuel distributors at a rate of four-tenths of one cent per gallon, with revenues directed to both the Mississippi Groundwater Protection Trust Fund and the State Highway Fund. To the extent this “environmental protection fee” is used to generate revenue for the State Highway Fund rather than to simply recoup the costs of providing a service to specific beneficiaries, it may meet the legal definition of a tax rather than a fee.
- A provision dedicating revenue from the tax on sports betting, which was recently legalized in the state, to the State Highway Fund through June 2028, and then to the General Fund. While the introduction of a new legal market for gambling brings with it an initial surge of activity and revenue, long-term revenue is difficult to predict. The tax rate on legal gambling plays a role in how much activity is shifted away from the black market, and as new competition enters the market, revenue can be expected to fluctuate.
Earlier this year, House Speaker Philip Gunn (R) floated a “tax swap” proposal, which would have phased in a gas tax increase of two cents per year over four years, and then indexed the final rate for inflation, while reducing individual income taxes to offset the gas tax increase. We wrote about the benefits of the tax swap plan; namely, using a tax on road usage to fund infrastructure improvements that primarily benefit road users.
This time around, lawmakers ultimately opted to use piecemeal tax changes as part of their approach to infrastructure funding, and they walked out of this month’s special session with a plan to address the state’s most urgent infrastructure repair needs. However, ten years from now, when lottery tax revenue and sports betting tax revenue are no longer allocated to infrastructure, and revenue trends are reanalyzed, legislators may again face a set of challenging decisions related to infrastructure funding.
Was this page helpful to you?
The Tax Foundation works hard to provide insightful tax policy analysis. Our work depends on support from members of the public like you. Would you consider contributing to our work?Contribute to the Tax Foundation
Let us know how we can better serve you!
We work hard to make our analysis as useful as possible. Would you consider telling us more about how we can do better?Give Us Feedback