Congressman Nunes Proposes a Bold New Approach to Taxing Business

October 12, 2012

Chronic unemployment, slow growth, and a worsening debt crisis should tell us the present course is not working. Congressman Nunes writes in today's Washington Post that a big part of the problem is how our tax code (mis)treats business:

“We need to dramatically change the tax code so that investing is not only easier for businesses but becomes a far better option than not investing.

The current debate over tax policy focuses on whether we should raise taxes and, if so, whether to raise them on individuals making more than $200,000 a year or on millionaires. We need to talk about the bigger picture: what it takes to get people and businesses to invest their money and create jobs.

That is what the American Business Competitiveness tax reform, which I intend to introduce in Congress, would achieve. Designed to complement current congressional efforts on tax reform, the ABC tax reform would replace the business tax structure with a new form of consumption tax. Many macroeconomists recognize consumption taxes as the best tax system for encouraging capital investment and economic growth.

Most of the world’s consumption taxes are sales taxes or value-added taxes (VATs). The ABC tax reform is different — it would encourage business investment by allowing 100 percent expensing in the current year. This means that companies of any size, no matter how they’re organized, would pay no taxes on any of their spending for personnel, equipment, property or other expenditure related to the operation of their business in the United States.

Expensing — essentially, tax deductions for business investment — is allowed under the current tax code but is subject to innumerable and ever-changing conditions and limits; what a company can expense depends on a firm’s size and industry, the type of asset bought and its cost, the amount of time over which the firm can deduct costs (“depreciation”) and whether the business is entitled to “bonus depreciation” measures. By replacing this convoluted system with a uniform rule of 100 percent expensing, the ABC tax reform would quickly spark economic growth. Simply put, the more a company invests and expands, the more it reduces the percentage of its income that is taxed.

To boost growth even further, non-expensed income for all businesses would be taxed at one low, globally competitive rate — 25 percent — and all credits, special deals and loopholes on the business side would be eliminated. Because all businesses, whether a mom-and-pop grocery or a billion-dollar conglomerate, would be subject to the same clear rules and rate, special interests and big business would no longer be able to manipulate the tax code.”

Read the whole article, it’s a great illustration of all the problems that plague the tax code, including the long standing bias against saving and investing, the lack of transparency, and the vicious cycle of more loopholes in exchange for higher rates. In particular, full expensing, as opposed to depreciation, addresses all of these problems in a consistent way. Most importantly, it is likely to boost investment dramatically, leading to more hiring and purchases today, and more sustainable and robust economic growth over the long run.

While we look forward to hearing more details about his plan, it is safe to say that the Congressman is on precisely the right track.

Follow William McBride on Twitter @EconoWill

Related Articles