Skip to content

Portland’s Proposed Fair Share Tax Yields Astronomical Tax Burdens

7 min readBy: Jared Walczak

Under the Fair Share Tax, a proposal pending before Portland City Council, some corporations could soon face a 26.2 percent state and local income taxA tax is a mandatory payment or charge collected by local, state, and national governments from individuals or businesses to cover the costs of general government services, goods, and activities. rate, plus a 1.57 percent gross receipts taxGross receipts taxes are applied to a company’s gross sales, without deductions for a firm’s business expenses, like compensation, costs of goods sold, and overhead costs. Unlike a sales tax, a gross receipts tax is assessed on businesses and applies to transactions at every stage of the production process, leading to tax pyramiding. rate (not accounting for a partial deduction for the cost of labor or cost of goods sold, which will vary by business). For a business with a 7 percent profit margin, that represents a 48.6 percent rate on net income just from state and local income and gross receipts taxes, before even considering federal taxes or local property taxes. But one of the proposal’s co-sponsors, City Councilor Mitch Green (D-District 4), argues the proposed tax shouldn’t be a concern because, he contends, Portland’s current business taxes aren’t actually high.

He is mistaken.

The Councilor’s proposal would add a multiplier to the existing city business license (income) tax with rates based on CEO compensation ratios, with the highest rate set at 15.6 percent—higher than the highest state corporate income taxA corporate income tax (CIT) is levied by federal and state governments on business profits. Many companies are not subject to the CIT because they are taxed as pass-through businesses, with income reportable under the individual income tax. of 11.5 percent in New Jersey. This would be in addition to Oregon’s 7.6 percent top state corporate income tax rate, a 2 percent county tax, a 1 percent regional tax, and both city and state gross receipts taxes.

Councilor Green contends that Portland’s current business tax burdens are reasonable and specifically objects to our prior analysis, which finds that Portland has some of the highest business taxes in the country. But can his claim be true? Is it possible that, as his office purports to show, Portland’s business taxes are almost 40 percent lower than Pittsburgh’s and barely a quarter of Seattle’s?

The answer is, of course, no: Portland is a uniquely high-tax jurisdiction, and the calculations the Councilor relies on are deeply flawed. The results raise obvious red flags, such as the fact that the calculations for Seattle yield a 142 percent effective tax rate for a typical business from sales, payroll, and gross receipts taxes alone. Even without considering federal income taxes, local property taxes, or any other taxes, Councilor Green’s comparative tables show a Seattle business paying the entirety of its profits, and then 42 percent more, in state and local taxes. Seattle’s taxes are high, but they aren’t that high.

It’s worth understanding how these calculations went awry, because correcting the errors yields precisely the conclusion that the so-called Fair Share Tax’s sponsor attempts to disprove: Portland’s business taxes are already uniquely high.

Both Portland and the state of Oregon have gross receipts taxes, which are major drivers of the region’s high business tax burdens, though a constellation of state, regional, county, and city income taxes also contribute significantly to the overall tax bill. Oregon does not, however, levy a sales taxA sales tax is levied on retail sales of goods and services and, ideally, should apply to all final consumption with few exemptions. Many governments exempt goods like groceries; base broadening, such as including groceries, could keep rates lower. A sales tax should exempt business-to-business transactions which, when taxed, cause tax pyramiding. —one of five states to forgo one. The Councilor’s analysis attempts an “apples-to-apples” comparison by converting other jurisdictions’ taxes into gross receipts tax equivalents, but errs in several respects, nowhere more significantly than in the conversion of general sales taxes into gross receipts tax equivalents.

The Councilor’s FAQ recognizes that sales tax calculations drive the results but fails to recognize that the calculations are gravely in error. After a table comparing Portland to several other jurisdictions, the text reads: “Notice that Portland’s various tax rates sum to a fairly large number, just under Seattle’s. But after converting to the equivalent tax on gross receipts, these rates become very small. Indeed, because Oregon and the jurisdictions therein do not have a sales tax, the actual tax burden is much lower than other cities.”

It is not. The conversion is wrong.

In Seattle, for instance, sales taxes are estimated to cost businesses 5.93 percent of gross revenue, which is almost 85 percent of the income of a business with 7 percent profit margins. Seattle’s sales taxes alone are estimated to impose as much as 243 percent of the total business tax burden calculated for Portland (2.44 to 2.54 percent of gross revenue), which is clearly mistaken.

The Councilor’s analysis converts sales tax rates into gross receipts equivalents by dividing the general sales tax rate by 1.78 percent, based on a misinterpretation of a paper that estimates 1.78 as the ratio of gross receipts to final consumption. The paper’s estimate is entirely reasonable and is essentially identical to the ratio of US gross output to GDP. It is a ratio of all transactions to consumption and has nothing to do with sales taxes.

Total consumption is not the same as taxable sales. It includes transactions largely excluded from sales tax bases (like healthcare, insurance, groceries, and legal services), and it even includes consumption that does not involve a transaction, like the imputed value of living in one’s own home. And while some business-to-business transactions are taxed, and their costs are at least partially borne by businesses, it’s also clearly mistaken to apply all the cost of sales taxes—a consumer tax—to businesses.

The magnitude of this error can be demonstrated by applying the Councilor’s methodology to sales taxes nationwide. That yields $2.37 trillion in business sales tax burdens in FY 2024, whereas total state and local sales tax collections were about $588 billion, including both consumer and business purchases.

To put this in further context, EY and the Council on State Taxation estimate that businesses paid about $245 billion that year, one-tenth of what Councilor Green’s methodology suggests. Federal corporate income tax collections were $472 billion in FY 2024, making the Councilor’s estimates of businesses’ share of state and local sales tax burdens five times what the federal government collects in corporate income tax revenue.

In other words, the primary reason Portland’s taxes look modest compared with other jurisdictions is that the analysis takes the one major tax Oregon lacks and overstates its burdens by a factor of ten.

The comparison also contains other errors and omissions. It applies Seattle’s Social Housing Tax, which applies only to compensation above $1 million per employee, and its JumpStart Housing Tax, which applies only to larger businesses, to all wages. It lists Pennsylvania’s corporate income tax but drops it from Pittsburgh’s total tax calculation, omits California’s corporate income tax entirely, excludes Oregon’s TriMet employer payroll taxA payroll tax is a tax paid on the wages and salaries of employees to finance social insurance programs like Social Security, Medicare, and unemployment insurance. Payroll taxes are social insurance taxes that comprise 24.8 percent of combined federal, state, and local government revenue, the second largest source of that combined tax revenue., applies Portland’s Clean Energy Surcharge to all businesses, and disregards deductions under the Oregon CAT. These errors cut both ways, but they indicate a haphazard approach. Property taxes (on real property as well as machinery and equipment), which represent about 34 percent of all state and local taxes paid by businesses, are also omitted, though this omission is acknowledged.

The Councilor’s own analysis yields a 36.3 percent effective rate on a business with 7 percent profit margins from state and local business income and gross receipts taxes alone, even before the new tax, which is astonishingly high. It’s too high, in fact, due to several calculation errors. But the reality is that Portland’s taxes are very high, and the Councilor’s analysis does nothing to contradict that. It merely compares it favorably to vastly inflated rates in other jurisdictions.

These are not just calculation errors. They also flow through into the broader analysis.

The Councilor’s FAQ argues, for instance, that low-margin businesses like grocery store chains will be able to handle an increased tax burden in Portland since the increase is supposedly minuscule compared to “the actual sales taxes in Vancouver, Washington, where there are plenty of grocery stores despite state and local taxes 45 times higher than this ordinance proposes.” Not only does this rely on the previously mentioned miscalculation of sales tax burdens, converting an 8.9 percent sales tax into a 5 percent tax on grocers’ gross receipts—an impossible 250 percent effective rate from sales tax alone, based on the Councilor’s correct identification of grocery store profit margins as about 2 percent—but it misses the fact that Washington, like most states, exempts groceries from the sales tax.

Portland already has anomalously high business taxes, and the proposed tax would make those rates astronomical. Business taxes imposed based on sales into a jurisdiction tend to show up in prices, meaning Portland consumers would bear a substantial share of the increased tax burden, even if large corporations are the ones to remit the tax. Some businesses may find that they can no longer afford to operate in Portland at all, reducing consumer choice and undercutting local employment.

As Portland City Council considers the proposed tax increase, they should understand the city’s starting point—as arguably the highest-tax jurisdiction in the entire country—not one of the lowest.

Stay informed on the tax policies impacting you.

Subscribe to our free newsletter to get the latest tax data, news and analysis.

Subscribe
Share this article

About the Author

Jared Walczak Tax Foundation
Expert

Jared Walczak

Senior Fellow

Jared Walczak is a Senior Fellow at the Tax Foundation, where he spent five years as Vice President of State Projects, and president of Walczak Policy Consulting.