A group of professors recently released a study that finds insufficient discussion of the total cost of taxes in public finance textbooks. They find that common textbooks fail to fully include the total cost of taxes...
- The Tax Policy Blog
- PolitiFact's "Half True" Ruling on State B...
PolitiFact's "Half True" Ruling on State Beer Taxes
Earlier this month, when we published a map of state excise tax rates on beer, we received an unexpected response from PolitiFact Tennessee (a joint project of the Memphis Commercial Appeal and the Knoxville News Sentinel). They rated our listing of Tennessee’s state excise tax rate on beer as “False.” We’ve been working on state tax policy since 1937 and publishing data on beer taxes since 1950, so being called out like this was rather surprising – especially given that the figure (in this case $0.14 per gallon) was actually correct.
The PolitiFact team was motivated to write on the topic after representatives of the brewing industry complained on Twitter about Tennessee’s ranking. The state has the 39th highest beer excise tax in the country, but the aggrieved brewers pointed out that there are other taxes in Tennessee that increase the final price of beer as well, in particular a 17% wholesale sales tax.
Responding to the original article by PolitiFact Tennessee, we pointed out that while this is correct, it is irrelevant to the question of whether our map should be considered “True” or “False.” The map was titled “State Beer Excise Tax Rates (Dollars Per Gallon),” and it accurately lists the dollars-per-gallon state excise tax rate on beer in Tennessee and every other state. That makes it true.
The writers and editors at PolitiFact Tennessee responded quickly and politely to our pointing this out, and promised to review the story and its conclusion. After additional phone calls and email messages were exchanged, they issued a revised ruling, calling the data on our map “Half True.” Again, we take issue with this ruling.
Toward the end of the revised piece, the writers emphasize that beer company executives find it “infuriating” when anyone highlights the state excise rate without simultaneously acknowledging the wholesale sales tax that also adds to the cost of their product. With all due respect to both journalists and brewers from the Volunteer State, however, that does not change the definition of what is true. We published accurate excise rate data, and no amount of fury emanating from beer industry lobbyists in Tennessee is going to change that accurate data into being only “Half True.”
Subscribe to the Tax Foundation Newsletter
Join the Tax Foundation's fight for sound tax policy Go
About the Tax Policy Blog
The Tax Policy Blog is the official weblog of the Tax Foundation, a non-partisan, non-profit research organization that has monitored tax policy at the federal, state and local levels since 1937. Our economists welcome your feedback. If you would like to send an e-mail to the author of a blog post, please click on that person's name to locate his or her e-mail address or visit our staff page here.