Unpublished JCT Estimates of Congressional Democrats’ “Plan” on Expiring Tax Cuts
August 13, 2010
Yesterday, the Washington Post, New York Times and other news sources ran stories about a new JCT "report" that was sent to Democratic congressional staff relating to the distribution of their proposal versus the Republican proposal (and current law) regarding the expiring "Bush" tax cuts.
Washington Post blogger Ezra Klein popularized this chart that was in yesterday's Post that eventually received a lot of attention in the liberal webosphere. Klein's blog headline read "The Bush tax plan vs. the Obama tax plan in one chart."
Unfortunately, it is not technically Obama's tax plan. The plan was submitted by congressional staff Democrats and differs somewhat from the tax policies outlined in President Obama's budget. We looked at this plan after the Tax Foundation received calls concerning how this plan differs from the plan that is in the third column on the MyTaxBurden.org calculator, "Obama's Budget."
The Obama tax plan includes a one-year extension of the Making Work Pay credit, which this proposal sent to JCT does not. Furthermore, this plan sent to JCT does not include an extension of Pres. Obama's new education credits. Finally, it is does not include an additional tax on high-income taxpayers that would have limited the tax savings value of their itemized deductions.
JCT did score a proposal that would also extend parts of the tax provisions in the stimulus bill (EITC and additional child tax credit expansion), but it appears that an extension of Making Work Pay isn't a top priority of congressional tax staff.
If the Making Work Pay credit is allowed to expire (as it probably should eventually), technically, Americans will see lower paychecks in January compared to December. Those paychecks will still be much bigger in January relative to a scenario of the tax cuts not being extended.