Pennsylvania?s Windfall Profits Tax?
February 9, 2007
If Governor Edward Rendell gets his way, consumers, investors and workers in the Keystone State will face a massive tax hike. From the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette:
“A controversial “gross profits tax” on oil companies was one of the centerpieces of Mr. Rendell’s budget address yesterday, and the governor devoted a healthy portion of his annual speech to the issue of ExxonMobil’s record profits over the last three years.
“These profits have come from one source — the pockets of the American people,” Mr. Rendell said near the end of his 55-minute speech. “It is time for the oil companies to finally pay their fair share of the transportation tax burden in Pennsylvania.” [Full Story]
Governor Rendell’s proposed “windfall profits tax” would set a dangerous new precedent of targeting politically unpopular industries for special taxation at the state level. Of course Uncle Sam tried a federal windfall profits tax to punish the oil industry in the 1980s and it proved to be economically devastating.
When we last tried a windfall profits tax, it failed to raise a fraction of the revenue forecasted and crippled the production of the domestic oil industry. As they say, those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
While Governor Rendell bemoans ExxonMobil’s record profits, he conveniently neglects to mention the amount of taxes they paid or remitted. In 2006 alone, ExxonMobil’s total tax burden was over $100 billion – that’s roughly two and a half times what they made in profits.
That trend is nothing new. The nation’s energy companies are already providing a “windfall” of taxes. According to Department of Energy data, from 1977 to 2004, federal and state governments extracted $397 billion by taxing the profits of the largest oil companies and an additional $1.1 trillion in taxes at the pump. In today’s dollars, that’s $2.2 trillion.
Oil companies pay billions more to governments in off-shore royalties, severance taxes, property taxes, and payroll taxes – the list goes on and reads like the Yellow Pages.
These taxes come from one source – the pockets of the American people.
Real people – not inanimate business entities – pay the true burden of business taxes. Any tax paid by business is immediately transferred onto individuals in three ways.
The first to pay are the employees of oil companies here in the U.S. – people who would make lower wages or perhaps even lose their jobs. Next would be the millions of Americans who have investments in the oil industry – people who would earn lower returns on those investments. In fact, retirement and pension accounts now hold 41 percent of the shares of America’s oil and gas companies.
Finally, the principal group to pay would be American gasoline customers – the millions of people who would pay more at the pump.
If Governor Rendell’s windfall profits tax proposal succeeds, one thing is clear – we’ll all pay the price.
To read additional Tax Foundation work on energy taxes, click here.
Was this page helpful to you?
The Tax Foundation works hard to provide insightful tax policy analysis. Our work depends on support from members of the public like you. Would you consider contributing to our work?Contribute to the Tax Foundation
Let us know how we can better serve you!
We work hard to make our analysis as useful as possible. Would you consider telling us more about how we can do better?Give Us Feedback