Indiana Tackles Throwback Rule and Personal Property Tax
June 30, 2015
Indiana’s 2015 General Assembly session ended just about two months ago. While this year’s tax code reforms were less extensive than past sessions, the legislature made welcome fixes to two policies in particular: the throwback rule and personal property taxes.
The throwback rule is a little-known but important part of the corporate tax code that determines a given company’s tax base. In corporate tax law, multi-state corporations have to apportion their income to the states they operate in based on some weighing of the corporation’s property, payroll, and sales. In Indiana, the apportionment method is entirely based on sales.
States with a throwback rule dictate that a corporation must apportion 100 percent of profits to the states. But because each state has a different apportionment method, sometimes certain income goes untaxed—this income is called “nowhere income.” Throwback rules, which exist in 25 states and DC, throw that nowhere income back into the taxable base.
While Indiana has one of the lowest corporate tax burdens in the country, the throwback rule very frequently complicates corporate income taxation. In the process of trying to capture nowhere income, multiple states can claim the right to tax the same income, creating more complexity for tax authorities and businesses. By eliminating the rule, Indiana lawmakers have made a major improvement in the state’s tax treatment of corporations.
In addition, state legislators enacted an exemption from the personal property tax for small businesses with up to $20,000 of personal property in a county. This policy is in line with recommendations we made in our comprehensive review of tangible personal property taxes in 2012, and also in testimony to the Indiana House Ways & Means Committee last legislative session.
Tangible personal property taxes place an inordinate tax burden on accumulation of machinery, equipment, and tools, and also contribute significantly to compliance costs because adding up all of a business’s physical capital and depreciating each item based on how old it is takes a lot of accountants. The new de minimis exemption takes away a lot of this compliance cost for small businesses in the state.
Currently, Indiana sits at 8th place in the Tax Foundation’s State Business Tax Climate Index, and is expected to rise to 7th as a result of tax cuts enacted over the last few years. These most recent refroms are one more step advancing Indiana’s reputation as one of the best tax codes in the country.
Was this page helpful to you?
The Tax Foundation works hard to provide insightful tax policy analysis. Our work depends on support from members of the public like you. Would you consider contributing to our work?Contribute to the Tax Foundation
Let us know how we can better serve you!
We work hard to make our analysis as useful as possible. Would you consider telling us more about how we can do better?Give Us Feedback