Inversions have been in the news consistently this summer as multiple companies have looked for legal paths away from the U.S. corporate tax system. Burger King became the latest corporation to add to the list after they...
- The Tax Policy Blog
- Tennessee Legislature's Effort to Drive a Stake Thro...
Tennessee Legislature's Effort to Drive a Stake Through the Heart of Wage Taxation Passes Senate
The roster of states that refuse to tax wages stands at nine out of fifty, as it has for almost 20 years. (Connecticut joined the wage-taxers in 1991.) Among those nine states, Tennessee is the one that has come closest to adopting a wage tax.
The year was 2002, during the last recession, and the political parties did not align predictably. Facing a budget crisis that had shut down state government on July 1, Republican governor Don Sundquist favored the new wage tax, but the Democrat-controlled state legislature wouldn't give him one. Reporter Michael Wilson at The New York Times set the wild Independence Day scene.
Tennessee's reaction to the most recent recession and its attendant budget problems has been much different. Instead of a nearly successful effort to tax wages, the legislature is pushing to amend the constitution to make such an enactment nearly impossible.
As reported by State Tax Today (subscription), the state senate has voted by 25 to 7 to approve SJR 763, which would amend the constitution to prohibit a state income or payroll tax. Next step is a vote in the House Budget Subcommittee, and even then it would have to be approved by the 107th General Assembly, which meets in 2011 and 2012, before being referred to voters in 2014. A long process suited to constitutional amendments.
As colleague Joe Henchman pointed out a couple weeks ago, Tennessee's courts have repeatedly ruled that the state legislature already has no power under the state constitution to enact a wage tax, but considering how close it got eight years ago, the current effort to make the constitution more emphatic on the matter may be understandable.
Technically, Tennessee already has an income tax, but it only applies to investment income from dividends and interest, most of which flows to the wealthiest people. The new effort to make wage taxation clearly unconstitutional protects this pre-existing tax on investment income.
Tax Foundation has more info on Tennessee.
Subscribe to the Tax Foundation Newsletter
Join the Tax Foundation's fight for sound tax policy Go
About the Tax Policy Blog
The Tax Policy Blog is the official weblog of the Tax Foundation, a non-partisan, non-profit research organization that has monitored tax policy at the federal, state and local levels since 1937. Our economists welcome your feedback. If you would like to send an e-mail to the author of a blog post, please click on that person's name to locate his or her e-mail address or visit our staff page here.