In the Tuesday Wall Street Journal, Professor Alan Blinder wrote of his puzzlement at the very slow growth of productivity in the last three years. There is really no mystery. The rate of growth of investment in...
- The Tax Policy Blog
- Sanford Proposes to Vastly Improve South Carolina's ...
Sanford Proposes to Vastly Improve South Carolina's Business Tax Climate
Today, South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford announced a sweeping tax reform proposal that would vastly improve the state's business tax climate. The proposal has several planks:
- Beginning in 2010, personal income tax filers could choose an optional flat tax rate of 3.65% with no deductions. The graduated table, which would continue to be available, has six rates, topping out at 7% on taxable income over $12,850. The optional flat tax would move South Carolina from having one of the highest top income tax rates in the South to the lowest, except for Texas and Florida, which have no personal income tax at all.
- The graduated tax brackets would be fully indexed to inflation. Currently, the brackets are indexed, but grow at a rate below inflation. The current system results in "bracket creep" where a taxpayer whose real income is unchanged from year to year can face higher tax rates over time.
- Corporate income tax would be phased out over a period of ten years. This phaseout would be offset in part by an elimination of corporate tax incentives over the same period. Because South Carolina will have a very low business tax burden, Sanford believes that corporate tax incentives should no longer be necessary.
- The cigarette tax would rise from 7 cents (currently the lowest in the nation) to 37 cents. While cigarette taxes are a predatory (and regressive) tax on a political minority, South Carolina's rate would still be well below the national average.
- A new, $3 per ton "tipping fee" would be imposed on landfill dumping.
- Sales tax holidays, a pet peeve of ours here at the Tax Foundation, would be abolished. (Yay!) Sales tax holidays make the tax code more complicated, distort economic decision-making, don't appear to foster economic activity, and are a gimmicky distraction from real tax relief.
- A committee would examine the inequities in the property tax structure that currently affect businesses. While I'm not intimately familiar with South Carolina's system of property taxation, many states tax commercial property at a higher rate than residential property. This hides the tax burden (as residential property taxes are more visible to individuals than business property taxes) and distorts economic decisionmaking (as it makes the cost to own commercial property artificially high).
All in all, this sounds like a very effective plan for improving South Carolina's business tax climate. It embodies the Tax Foundation's five principles of sound tax policy: simplicity, stability, neutrality, transparency, and growth-promotion.
Indeed, I entered the proposed changes into our State Business Tax Climate Index model, and found that if South Carolina adopted the plan today as fully phased in (i.e., with no tax on corporate income) the state would move from #25 to #6 on the Index, placing just behind Florida and ahead of all other states in the South. That would be a sea change (the opposite of the kind Maryland recently had) and make the state much more attractive for business investment from a tax perspective.
We'll keep you posted as Sanford tries to get the plan through South Carolina's sometimes-hostile legislature.
Subscribe to the Tax Foundation Newsletter
Join the Tax Foundation's fight for sound tax policy Go
About the Tax Policy Blog
The Tax Policy Blog is the official blog of the Tax Foundation, a non-partisan, non-profit research organization that has monitored tax policy at the federal, state and local levels since 1937. Our economists welcome your feedback. If you would like to send an e-mail to the author of a blog post, please click on that person's name to locate his or her e-mail address or visit our staff page here.