Illinois continues to struggle with its budget. The state’s most recent stopgap budget expired on December 31, 2016. To perhaps break up the political logjam, Illinois senators of both political parties have begun...
- The Tax Policy Blog
- Missouri Amendment Four: Preventing Sales Tax Base Expans...
Missouri Amendment Four: Preventing Sales Tax Base Expansions
Voters in Missouri will be asked to make an important choice in November: Should the sales tax apply to services? Dubbed the “Taxpayer Protection Amendment,” Amendment 4, pushed by the Missouri Association of Realtors, would prohibit adding any “service or transaction” to the state or local sales tax base if it was not taxed as of January 1, 2015. If proponents of Amendment 4 get their way, the Missouri legislature and governor would not be able to add any new service to the sales tax base, stifling the state’s ability to properly reform its tax code.
The broad exemption of services is a historical accident, not an intentional policy choice. When Mississippi passed the nation’s first sales tax in the early 1930s, the economy was largely compromised of goods. Service transactions represented a very small part of the economy, so they were not included in the sales tax statute. As other states copied Mississippi’s structure, services were broadly exempted in all states.
However, the economy of 1930 Mississippi differs greatly from the economy of 2016. Services comprise a large part, approximately two-thirds, of the current United States economy. By not including these service transactions, state sales tax bases are increasingly narrow, leading to higher rates than otherwise necessary.
States continue to explore expanding their sales tax base to include services. North Carolina’s dramatic tax reform of 2013 included such changes. Governor Wolf in Pennsylvania proposed taxing services in 2015. Texas already taxes a number of personal services, such as dry cleaning, landscaping, and barber services. (A more complete list of states that tax services can be found in our 2017 State Business Tax Climate Index.)
If Missouri voters limit the state’s ability to include services in its sales tax base, the state’s options for tax reform become more limited. As the sales tax base continues to erode, the state will need to find revenue in other places, with no good solutions. It could raise the sales tax rate, but Missouri already has the 14th highest sales tax rate in the country. It could raise its individual income tax, but it has the 19th highest individual income tax rate, and is tied with California for the most brackets in the country. The state’s corporate income tax rate is around the national average, but raising that makes little sense as the corporate income tax is one of the most harmful taxes to economic growth.
Proponents of the amendment are various service providers, concerned that their services could be taxed for the first time.
States should continue to explore ways to tax services, with the necessary considerations for business-to-business transactions. Eliminating the ability of Missouri to expand its sales tax base in the future will hamper the state’s ability to reform its tax code in the future, limiting the ability of the state to compete regionally and nationally.
Get Email Updates from the Tax Foundation
Join the Tax Foundation's fight for sound tax policy Go
About the Tax Policy Blog
The Tax Policy Blog is the official blog of the Tax Foundation, a non-partisan, non-profit research organization that has monitored tax policy at the federal, state and local levels since 1937. Our economists welcome your feedback. If you would like to send an e-mail to the author of a blog post, please click on that person's name to locate his or her e-mail address or visit our staff page here.
Recent Blog Posts
Related State Articles
- Will a New St. Louis Stadium Sales Tax Proposal be a Shutout?
- Lunch Links: Clinton Holds Back Details on Business Tax Plan; Leading Economists Sign Letter of Opposition to Trump; Los Angeles Weighs Separate Marijuana Taxes from Statewide Proposition; Kansas Once Again Misses Revenue Projection
- Lunch Links: Schumer Pushes for Social Security Boost; Impact of Passing Tobacco Tax Initiatives in Missouri; Marylanders to Vote on Further Tax for Subway Improvements
- 1 of 21
- next ›