In a recent Pew poll, 72 percent of Americans said that they were bothered by how complex the federal tax system is. These taxpayers are justified in their complaints: as of 2015, federal tax laws and regulations have...
- The Tax Policy Blog
- Mississippi Lawmakers Consider Firearm Sales Tax Holiday
Mississippi Lawmakers Consider Firearm Sales Tax Holiday
The Mississippi House of Representatives is considering a bill that would create a new state sales tax holiday for firearms, ammunition, and other hunting equipment, similar to a firearm holiday in neighboring Louisiana. The bill cleared the House Ways and Means Committee last Tuesday.
[A]rchery equipment, accessories, animal feed, apparel, shoes, bags, float tubes, binoculars, tools, firearm and archery cases, firearm and archery accessories, range finders, knives, decoys, tree stands, blinds, chairs, optics, hearing protection and enhancements, holsters, belts slings, and off-road vehicles and vessels such as all-terrain vehicles, airboats, pirogues and other boats.
The legislation’s sponsor, House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Jeff Smith, touted that the holiday “covers everything but the lunch you bring with you.”
Mississippi already has one tax-free weekend in the summer for clothing under $100. Sixteen other states have similar holidays for items such as back-to-school supplies, computers, and Energy Star appliances (check out our report on the topic for more details).
We’ve often been critical of sales tax holidays in the past—most recently in response to a proposal by Florida Governor Rick Scott. Below are the arguments we made against them then, but they’re equally relevant here:
- Sales tax holidays do not promote economic growth and do not pay for themselves. Proponents argue that consumers buy more of the tax-free goods since they are now cheaper and will make impulse purchases on other items, thus generating more tax revenue. This doesn’t happen in reality. All sales tax holidays do is shift consumption to a different point in time, not generate more overall sales. (Here are a few studies demonstrating this effect: one, and two.) There’s also plenty of anecdotes on the shifting of consumer purchases to take advantage of a holiday (check out footnote 7 of our paper on the topic, where we summarize quite a few).
- Sales tax holidays don’t create permanent jobs. If anything, retailers might have to add extra part-time or temporary employees to help during the holiday due to increased foot traffic. This has big associated compliance costs. Imagine having to hire and train employees just for this short period of time. It wouldn’t merely cost a significant amount of time, but it would have monetary costs, as well.
- Products exempted from tax during the holiday are arbitrarily picked. For example, take a look at what’s in and what’s out during Florida’s existing sales tax holiday. Backpacks aren’t subject to sales tax, but briefcases and duffel bags are. Notebook filler paper is tax-free, but computer and printer paper isn’t.
- Sales tax holidays have real economic costs for businesses because of their complexity. Businesses operate the other 360 or so days of the year under a sales tax system that is entirely different than the one they must comply with during the holiday. Large and small businesses alike must account for the detailed and arbitrary rules that apply under the holidays. For example: “Mississippi’s [existing] sales tax holiday regulations…permit the use of coupons, prohibit layaway sales but permit rain checks, and exclude shipping costs from the holiday. Virginia’s sales tax holiday permits layaway sales and rain checks, does not permit rebates to lower the sales price, and excludes shipping but includes handling…Texas exempts layaway sales as well as shipping, handling, and even installation costs as part of its Energy Star product tax holiday.”
The bill doesn’t have a fiscal note yet and awaits further action in the House. Mississippi lawmakers should remember that sales tax holidays are a gimmick—not real tax reform.
Get Email Updates from the Tax Foundation
We will never sell or share your information with third parties.
Join the Tax Foundation's fight for sound tax policy Go
About the Tax Policy Blog
The Tax Policy Blog is the official blog of the Tax Foundation, a non-partisan, non-profit research organization that has monitored tax policy at the federal, state and local levels since 1937. Our economists welcome your feedback. If you would like to send an e-mail to the author of a blog post, please click on that person's name to locate his or her e-mail address or visit our staff page here.