Next week, Nevada voters will cast their ballots and decide whether or not Nevada will institute a margin tax. The tax is a modified gross receipts tax (a type of tax only five other states have) and is modeled after the...
- The Tax Policy Blog
- Michigan Tax Amnesty Program Collects $76 Million, at Wha...
Michigan Tax Amnesty Program Collects $76 Million, at What Cost?
According to recent data, Michigan's 2011 state tax amnesty captured approximately $76 million in unpaid taxes. Lasting for only 45 days, the tax amnesty program allowed delinquent taxpayers to submit unpaid taxes (plus interest) with no penalties or threat of criminal prosecution. Despite falling short of its $88 million goal, Michigan State Treasurer Andy Dillon remarked, "I am very pleased with the success of the 2011 Tax Amnesty Program." The recent amnesty was the third of its kind in the state since 1986.
Over the last three decades, tax amnesties have become increasingly popular with state governments. In 1982, Arizona became the first state to hold a tax amnesty program. Since then, 44 other states (in addition to the District of Columbia) have held their own amnesties. In total, approximately 115 general tax amnesties have been enacted since their inception.
Tax amnesties are commonly praised for the revenue that they collect. However, these one-time cash injections come at a high cost. Amnesty programs distort healthy incentives by undermining taxpayer respect for the law and reducing the cost of tax evasion. The more frequently amnesties are held, the more reinforced these effects become. To avoid these consequences, repeated amnesty programs should be avoided. However, this rarely happens. Legislators often advertise tax amnesties as one time deals, only to endorse similar programs several years later. Of the 46 states that have held tax amnesties, 22 offered similar amnesties within 10 years of each other.
Additionally, the debate over tax amnesties often overlooks systemic problems within state tax codes. As we have said in the past,
Often lost in the amnesty issue is the fact that much of tax non-compliance is due to tax complexity. Is it difficult to overstate the level of complexity in both federal and state tax laws. While some individuals and businesses knowingly cheat on their taxes, the complexity of our tax laws ensures that many people will be non-compliant without even knowing it.
Complexity within the tax code increases compliance costs for law abiding citizens and hinders enforcement by government officials. In short, tax amnesties do not fix the "tax gap." They are merely a retroactive response to taxpayer noncompliance. Broadening the tax base as part of comprehensive tax reform would help to alleviate the fundamental problems of high enforcement costs and noncompliance that amnesty programs are created to address. However, until states start proactively embracing reform, tax amnesties will likely remain a popular, albeit hazardous revenue tool.
Subscribe to the Tax Foundation Newsletter
Join the Tax Foundation's fight for sound tax policy Go
About the Tax Policy Blog
The Tax Policy Blog is the official blog of the Tax Foundation, a non-partisan, non-profit research organization that has monitored tax policy at the federal, state and local levels since 1937. Our economists welcome your feedback. If you would like to send an e-mail to the author of a blog post, please click on that person's name to locate his or her e-mail address or visit our staff page here.